1
Fork 0
rust/compiler
Matthias Krüger b0cc78c091
Rollup merge of #129028 - compiler-errors:contra, r=lcnr
`impl_trait_overcaptures`: Don't worry about uncaptured contravariant lifetimes if they outlive a captured lifetime

**NOTE:** Review only the first commit carefully. The second one is just moving stuff around, so you can turn whitespace off for that one.

This PR relaxes the `impl_trait_overcaptures` lint to not fire in cases like:

```rust
struct Ctxt<'tcx>(&'tcx ());

impl<'tcx> Ctxt<'tcx> {
    fn compute(&self) -> impl Sized + '_ { }
}
```

Specifically, the lint will not fire if **all** overcaptured regions (i.e. those which will be captured in edition 2024, which are not captured today) **satisfy**:
* The region is contravariant (or bivariant) in the function signature
* The region outlives some other region which is captured by the opaque

### The idea behind this

Why is this OK? My reasoning is that since the region is contravariant in the function signature, we know that it can be shortened arbitrarily at the call site. And specifically, we know it can be shortened to be equal to one of the regions that it outlives -- that's why we need to prove that it outlives some other region that *is* captured.

We could technically relax this further, but there would be (IMO somewhat easy) cases to make this a false negative in real code. For example, if the region is invariant, then we can hit issues like:

```rust
struct Ctxt<'tcx>(&'tcx mut &'tcx mut ());

impl<'tcx> Ctxt<'tcx> {
    fn compute(&self) -> impl Sized + use<'_, 'tcx> { }
    // We use `use<'_, 'tcx>` to show what happens in edition 2024
}

fn test<'a, 'b>(x: &'a Ctxt<'b>, y: &'a Ctxt<'a>) {
    let results = [x.compute(), y.compute()];
    //~^ ERROR lifetime may not live long enough
    // Since both opaques now capture `'tcx`, this enforces that `'a == 'b`.
}
```

### Is this actually totally fine?

There's one case where users might still hit issues, and it's if we turbofish lifetimes directly:

```rust
struct Ctxt<'tcx>(&'tcx ());

impl<'tcx> Ctxt<'tcx> {
    fn compute(&self) -> impl Sized + use<'_, 'tcx> { }
}

fn test<'a, 'b>(x: &'a Ctxt<'b>, y: &'a Ctxt<'a>) {
    let results = [Ctxt::<'b>::compute(x), Ctxt::<'a>::compute(y)];
    //~^ ERROR lifetime may not live long enough
    // Since both opaques now capture `'tcx`, this enforces that `'a == 'b`.
    // Note that we don't shorten `'b` to `'a` since we turbofished it.
}
```

### Well... we should still warn?

I kinda don't care about this case, though I guess we could possibly downgrade the lint to something like `IMPL_TRAIT_OVERCAPTURES_STRICT` instead of suppressing it altogether. Thoughts? If we were to do this, then I'd probably also opt to include the invariant case in `IMPL_TRAIT_OVERCAPTURES_STRICT` and move it out of `IMPL_TRAIT_OVERCAPTURES`.
2024-09-05 18:58:54 +02:00
..
rustc disable size asserts in the compiler when randomizing layouts 2024-08-31 23:56:45 +02:00
rustc_abi inhibit layout randomization for Box 2024-08-31 23:56:45 +02:00
rustc_arena compiler: Remove feature(new_uninit) 2024-08-27 10:17:05 -07:00
rustc_ast Create opaque definitions in resolver. 2024-08-31 20:14:43 +00:00
rustc_ast_ir Add warn(unreachable_pub) to several crates. 2024-08-16 08:46:13 +10:00
rustc_ast_lowering chore: Fix typos in 'compiler' (batch 1) 2024-09-02 07:42:38 +02:00
rustc_ast_passes Create opaque definitions in resolver. 2024-08-31 20:14:43 +00:00
rustc_ast_pretty Add warn(unreachable_pub) to rustc_ast_pretty. 2024-08-16 08:46:46 +10:00
rustc_attr Rollup merge of #126013 - nnethercote:unreachable_pub, r=Urgau 2024-08-27 00:41:57 +02:00
rustc_baked_icu_data Don't add warn(unreachable_pub) to rustc_baked_icu. 2024-08-16 08:46:52 +10:00
rustc_borrowck chore: Fix typos in 'compiler' (batch 1) 2024-09-02 07:42:38 +02:00
rustc_builtin_macros Rollup merge of #123940 - kornelski:remove-derived-debug, r=Urgau 2024-08-29 16:21:46 +02:00
rustc_codegen_cranelift introduce PrettyPrintMirOptions for cosmetic MIR dump options 2024-08-30 07:07:28 +00:00
rustc_codegen_gcc Rollup merge of #128731 - RalfJung:simd-shuffle-vector, r=workingjubilee 2024-08-27 01:46:50 -05:00
rustc_codegen_llvm Rollup merge of #128820 - LYF1999:yf/dev, r=nikic 2024-09-05 18:58:53 +02:00
rustc_codegen_ssa Rollup merge of #129875 - Sajjon:sajjon_fix_typos_batch_1, r=compiler-errors,jieyouxu 2024-09-02 22:35:20 +02:00
rustc_const_eval Auto merge of #129777 - nnethercote:unreachable_pub-4, r=Urgau 2024-09-03 01:27:20 +00:00
rustc_data_structures chore: Fix typos in 'compiler' (batch 1) 2024-09-02 07:42:38 +02:00
rustc_driver
rustc_driver_impl Rollup merge of #101339 - the8472:ci-randomize-debug, r=Mark-Simulacrum 2024-09-05 03:47:39 +02:00
rustc_error_codes chore: Fix typos in 'compiler' (batch 1) 2024-09-02 07:42:38 +02:00
rustc_error_messages Add warn(unreachable_pub) to rustc_error_messages. 2024-08-27 11:52:08 +10:00
rustc_errors Rollup merge of #129875 - Sajjon:sajjon_fix_typos_batch_1, r=compiler-errors,jieyouxu 2024-09-02 22:35:20 +02:00
rustc_expand Add warn(unreachable_pub) to rustc_expand. 2024-08-27 12:40:38 +10:00
rustc_feature Rollup merge of #129664 - adetaylor:arbitrary-self-types-pointers-feature-gate, r=wesleywiser 2024-09-05 03:47:42 +02:00
rustc_fluent_macro Add warn(unreachable_pub) to rustc_fluent_macro. 2024-08-27 12:56:54 +10:00
rustc_fs_util Reformat use declarations. 2024-07-29 08:26:52 +10:00
rustc_graphviz Add warn(unreachable_pub) to rustc_graphviz. 2024-08-27 12:58:29 +10:00
rustc_hir Revert "Auto merge of #127537 - veluca93:struct_tf, r=BoxyUwU" 2024-09-01 16:35:53 +02:00
rustc_hir_analysis Rollup merge of #129664 - adetaylor:arbitrary-self-types-pointers-feature-gate, r=wesleywiser 2024-09-05 03:47:42 +02:00
rustc_hir_pretty Add warn(unreachable_pub) to rustc_hir_pretty. 2024-08-27 13:25:40 +10:00
rustc_hir_typeck Rollup merge of #129664 - adetaylor:arbitrary-self-types-pointers-feature-gate, r=wesleywiser 2024-09-05 03:47:42 +02:00
rustc_incremental Add warn(unreachable_pub) to rustc_incremental. 2024-08-27 14:30:20 +10:00
rustc_index disable size asserts in the compiler when randomizing layouts 2024-08-31 23:56:45 +02:00
rustc_index_macros
rustc_infer chore: Fix typos in 'compiler' (batch 1) 2024-09-02 07:42:38 +02:00
rustc_interface chore: Fix typos in 'compiler' (batch 1) 2024-09-02 07:42:38 +02:00
rustc_lexer Add warn(unreachable_pub) to rustc_lexer. 2024-08-27 15:12:46 +10:00
rustc_lint Review comments 2024-09-05 06:34:42 -04:00
rustc_lint_defs update docs of missing_abi lint 2024-09-04 14:30:56 +02:00
rustc_llvm Rollup merge of #129749 - krasimirgg:llvm-20-lto, r=nikic 2024-08-31 14:46:09 +02:00
rustc_log Reformat use declarations. 2024-07-29 08:26:52 +10:00
rustc_macros Add warn(unreachable_pub) to rustc_metadata. 2024-08-29 20:13:06 +10:00
rustc_metadata Make supertrait and implied predicates queries defaulted 2024-09-04 06:28:59 -04:00
rustc_middle Rollup merge of #101339 - the8472:ci-randomize-debug, r=Mark-Simulacrum 2024-09-05 03:47:39 +02:00
rustc_mir_build Revert "Auto merge of #127537 - veluca93:struct_tf, r=BoxyUwU" 2024-09-01 16:35:53 +02:00
rustc_mir_dataflow Adjust SanityCheck. 2024-09-03 15:18:30 +10:00
rustc_mir_transform Rollup merge of #129926 - nnethercote:mv-SanityCheck-and-MirPass, r=cjgillot 2024-09-03 19:13:27 +02:00
rustc_monomorphize chore: Fix typos in 'compiler' (batch 2) 2024-09-02 07:50:22 +02:00
rustc_next_trait_solver do not attempt to prove unknowable goals 2024-09-03 08:35:23 +02:00
rustc_parse chore: Fix typos in 'compiler' (batch 2) 2024-09-02 07:50:22 +02:00
rustc_parse_format Add warn(unreachable_pub) to rustc_parse_format. 2024-08-29 20:13:06 +10:00
rustc_passes Rollup merge of #128701 - veera-sivarajan:fix-128604, r=estebank 2024-09-03 19:13:23 +02:00
rustc_pattern_analysis Rollup merge of #128934 - Nadrieril:fix-empty-non-exhaustive, r=compiler-errors 2024-09-03 19:13:24 +02:00
rustc_privacy Add warn(unreachable_pub) to rustc_privacy. 2024-08-29 20:18:44 +10:00
rustc_query_impl Add warn(unreachable_pub) to rustc_query_impl. 2024-08-29 20:18:44 +10:00
rustc_query_system chore: Fix typos in 'compiler' (batch 2) 2024-09-02 07:50:22 +02:00
rustc_resolve Rollup merge of #129877 - Sajjon:sajjon_fix_typos_batch_2, r=fee1-dead 2024-09-02 22:35:21 +02:00
rustc_sanitizers Auto merge of #129777 - nnethercote:unreachable_pub-4, r=Urgau 2024-09-03 01:27:20 +00:00
rustc_serialize Auto merge of #129777 - nnethercote:unreachable_pub-4, r=Urgau 2024-09-03 01:27:20 +00:00
rustc_session Auto merge of #129777 - nnethercote:unreachable_pub-4, r=Urgau 2024-09-03 01:27:20 +00:00
rustc_smir Auto merge of #129777 - nnethercote:unreachable_pub-4, r=Urgau 2024-09-03 01:27:20 +00:00
rustc_span Rollup merge of #129664 - adetaylor:arbitrary-self-types-pointers-feature-gate, r=wesleywiser 2024-09-05 03:47:42 +02:00
rustc_symbol_mangling Auto merge of #129777 - nnethercote:unreachable_pub-4, r=Urgau 2024-09-03 01:27:20 +00:00
rustc_target Rollup merge of #127021 - thesummer:1-add-target-support-for-rtems-arm-xilinx-zedboard, r=tgross35 2024-09-05 03:47:40 +02:00
rustc_trait_selection Rollup merge of #129896 - lcnr:bail-on-unknowable, r=jackh726 2024-09-03 19:13:26 +02:00
rustc_traits Add warn(unreachable_pub) to rustc_traits. 2024-09-03 08:49:54 +10:00
rustc_transmute Auto merge of #129777 - nnethercote:unreachable_pub-4, r=Urgau 2024-09-03 01:27:20 +00:00
rustc_ty_utils Add warn(unreachable_pub) to rustc_ty_utils. 2024-09-03 08:50:33 +10:00
rustc_type_ir do not attempt to prove unknowable goals 2024-09-03 08:35:23 +02:00
rustc_type_ir_macros Reformat use declarations. 2024-07-29 08:26:52 +10:00
stable_mir chore: Fix typos in 'compiler' (batch 3) 2024-09-02 07:33:41 +02:00